Yeah, I'm pretty late to the party! If you want to know why, about a year ago, I suddenly realized what you all probably knew already and became obsessed with fanvids, my
analysis of
jarrow272 's "Save Yourself" in my dissertation might shed some light. So I've started keeping a
vid-watching diary . The logic behind this is that, when I save a fic, it's easy enough to click through to it again and skim the text to remind myself of what it's about and why I loved it, whereas with vids, there's really no shorthand way to re-access them. While fanworksfinder is working well for me as an archive, it doesn't offer a means to share my reviews. So when
counteragent declared the
New-To-Me Vid Watching Challenge , it occurred to me that I could take this as an opportunity not only to pledge, but to do a dump of all my recent vidrecs.
My long-term OCD project is cover Battlestar Galactica gen and
all the BSG vids on imeem with some comprehensiveness, complete with my best-of-the-best playlist -- but that's still in the early stages. For the moment, I've been catching up on
kbusse ,
jarrow272 , and
beerbad's recent recs posts. Of course, I never seem to be able to multitask, so I'm doing this in one massive blitz of ~50 vids. I got on an airplane yesterday with a stocked ipod and my Secretary swag notepad, and wrote pages and pages of comments out longhand while flying cross-country.
first, a fortnight's worth of vids that meet
counteragent 's criteria (new to me + I feedbacked [via my personal journal]), albeit late for the challenge and all in one day! I have a really difficult time commenting on posts that already have two or three or four pages of replies, is what I learned -- but I suppose that's why it's called a "challenge."
7 challenge vids: BSGvidder(s):
cherryice title: Only music: Nine Inch Nails
focus: Final Four + Sharon
availability: download (divx), imeem
summary: What does it take before you're considered a person?
comments: I was sort of afraid to watch this vid, because I had a suspicion that it would make my head explode with awesome -- and it did not disappoint! FLAIL. The definitive final
five four vid (I thought I was indifferent to such vids since three of them are boys; obviously I was wrong wrong wrong -- and there's even snippets of Tory/Laura in this, if you don't blink!), and so much more! Cylons have aaaaaaaangst, yo! I found this both deeply thought-provoking and (perversely?) rather humorous -- it's impossible not to be delighted by the sweeping connections and unironic rock. The thesis: robots try to find love, but in the end they're alone.
vidder(s):
hollywoodgrrl title: Lost Cause music: Beck
focus: ensemble
availability: download (wmv), youtube
summary: This vid is all about the Season 2 depression that everyone seemed to be suffering from.
comments: The perfect story of how these characters break our hearts, over and over again. The vid expertly daisy chains them together -- it's structurally clean without being schematic. And I SCREAMED at the end, omg! Gently devastating.
vidder(s):
laurashapiro and
sdwolfpup title: Let's Go Crazy music: Prince
focus: Gaius, ensemble
availability: download (divx avi),
imeem summary: Gaius Baltar doubts your commitment to sparkle motion (Club Vivid 07).
comments: I think one could experience this vid on multiple registers: it's Club Vivid, so it's bouncy and cracked-out and hilarious. But it also has something darker and deeper to say on the subject of "going crazy." In keeping with the vortex of Gaius, it features some pretty creepy sex and other varied perversions. The guitar riff montage at the end is especially ripe with insane genius!
vidder(s):
super_kc title: Battlestar Inferno music: Disco Inferno by 50 Cent
focus: ensemble
availability: stage6, imeem
summary: No plot, just hot. Pimps and hos. Rock it. Adult language and themes.
comments: We all know BSG is a supremely sexy show, but we didn't know just HOW sexy until this vid gave it to us, hard and fast, in one hip-grinding, sweat-soaked injection of pure smut. Also features probably the best ever use of the slow clap in a vid. :)
vidder(s):
charmax title: Mainstream music: Thea Gilmore
focus: Starbuck
availability: download (xvid avi), imeem
summary: This covers Starbuck from the mini series through to "Lay your burdens down" [ed: "Lay Down Your Burdens"]. It's a pilot's life.
comments: Starbuck's always on the move -- and she's moving to lesbian music! I don't know how it's even possible that I didn't watch this vid until now. Perfect for lovers of pre-angstified Starbuck, it's go go go through her life (complete with a cameo appearance by Cain!). Incorporates some truly amazing time-bridging sequences, including the one of her at her locker and the one of her jogging through hallways.
vidder(s):
bananainpyjamas (dragonchic)
title: A Place Inside music: "Scared of Girls" by Placebo
focus: Starbuck
availability: download (xvid avi, wmv), imeem
summary: Starbuck character study with a heavy emphasis on season three.
comments: The strength of this vid is how expertly it parallels and intertwines the web of intimate relationships in Starbuck's life (including Kat!), rendering their out-of-control trajectories through the more metaphorical movements of flying and, most provocatively, "destiny." The intercutting of Lee and Leoben is especially chilling!
vidder(s):
buffyann title: Headlights music: Archive
focus: Starbuck
availability: download (wmv/avi), stage6
summary: This is an attempt at showing Starbuck's struggle through life and through her "destiny" path.
comments: Season 3 Starbuck = OUCH. This vid captures her downward spiral into utter devastation, to a haunting song. Lovely, evocative use of images of the eye mandala, and paralleling of different dimensions of her life (flying and boxing, for example). [cheating: I did this one a couple of weeks ago]
7 challenge vids: miscellaneousvidder(s):
dualbunny title: Snakes on a Plane music: Cobra Starship
fandom: Harry Potter
availability: download (divx, wmv)
summary: Harry/Voldemort?? Harry has *had* it with the motherfuckin' snakes on his motherfuckin'
plane broom!
comments: Possibly the ultimate cult media mashup vid. Seriously, I have no words for the genius -- I mean, what could one say except MOTHERFUCKIN' SNAKES! Far more than a gimmick, though, this vid executes its ludicrous premise exquisitely, transcending its own crackitude to express something visually and intellectually magical about one of our culture's most enduring figures of evil (I'm not joking!).
vidder(s):
jescaflowne title: Another Sunday music: Jefferson Starship
fandom: SGA
availability: download (avi)
summary: "We built this city on rock n' roll" (Club Vivid 07)
comments: A self-consciously cheesy, gloriously retro, stylistically adventurous romp through the city of Atlantis! The genius of this vid is the virtuosity with which it marries the source to evocative visual codes of 80s culture, rendering its joy accessible to the non-viewer.
vidder(s):
mranderson71 title: Every Penguin Dance Now music: Rock This Party by Bob Sinclair
fandom: Happy Feet
availability: stage6, imeem
summary: Penguins! (Club Vivid 07)
comments: This vid is so flawless that the prowess of its technical achievement may not be immediately apparent. The Penguins appear as if they were dancing to this song all along! And part of the fun of animation is that they can also lip-sync (or beak-sync, in this case) to the lyrics. An exemplary dancevid.
vidder(s):
hollywoodgrrl title: (Boulevard of) Broken Songs music: Party Ben
fandom: Doctor Who
availability: download, imeem
summary: If Rose, Martha, Donna, and the Doctor all went to a pub together, these are the stories they each would tell after a couple rounds of the good stuff.
comments: Glorious on so many levels! First of all it's about the neglected COMPANIONS -- and what a worthy tribute it is. Secondly, I have a particular fondness for vids to mashups, and
hollywoodgrrl mobilizes this one to especially compelling effect by tying each component song to a different character. As she puts it, "I literally went with the notion that each companion tells her version of her story, and in the end, the Doctor jumps in and tells his" -- in other words, in addition to the mashup aesthetic, the vid carries over its underlying postmodern credo into its own conceptual register.
vidder(s):
laurashapiro and
killabeez title: Not Only Human music: Heather Nova
fandom: X-Files
availability: download (password),
imeem summary: Scully searches for answers, but finds only more questions.
comments: This vid is fully committed to Scully's POV, immersing itself in the theme of faith. Not the sexiest theme, but between Scully and the talented vidders, they make it sexy here. The sequence of scientific images gave me CHILLS, and by the end, the boundaries had blurred until I couldn't tell where the science ended and the faith began. Classic X-Files, and a classic vidding style.
vidder(s):
bradpcu title: Living Dead Girl music: Rob Zombie/Charlie Clouser
fandom: BtVS/AtS
availability: download (xvid avi), stage6
summary: Only one sure way to bring the giant down.
comments: Predictably, what fascinated me most were the self-reflexive references to a wide range of media texts and conventions (from silent film intertitles to TV static). I don't think their meaning is transparent, but they made for a very provocative juxtaposition with the highly corporeal horror imagery (blood, monsters, zombies, and more blood). Especially filtered through all the violence done by and to Faith (who I have to love, being our fanon dyke), I think there's a complex exploration of the ways gendered bodies are mediated folded into this vid.
vidder(s):
bradpcu title: Working Class Hero music: Green Day via John Lennon
fandom: Firefly/Serenity
availability: download (wmv)
summary: "If you want to be a hero well just follow me." Mal/River via Simon, Zoe, Jayne.
comments: The politics of Firefly! This vid makes a very clear, very hard-hitting intervention in/through the source, one encapsulated by the title. It's gritty, and difficult, and ambitious, and quite the rousing indictment of The Man.
other reviews: multifandomvidder(s):
counteragent title: Destiny Calling music: James
availability: imeem
summary: Made for the More Joy Day 2008 Challenge. Vids = JOY! This is a video commentary on the joy that other people’s vids brings me.
comments: The vid that makes all my cataloging and reccing work obsolete! A remarkable compilation of clips from remarkable vids, complete with some smart metatextual framing.
vidder(s): Jackie K
title: (If You Were) In My Movie music: Suzanne Vega
availability: DL at the bottom of the "misc" section (mpg [rar-ed])
summary: Jane and Daria work on a multimedia project.
comments: A powerful multifandom reverie on some of the tropes that run through mass media, and on media viewing itself. Includes a unique frame story constructed from Daria clips.
vidder(s):
sol_se title: Filthy Mind music: Amanda Ghost
availability: download (wmv, avi, mpeg), imeem
summary: A fandom free association, stream of consciousness. With dancing. (Club Vivid 07)
comments: A spectacular showcase of movement, with amazing cross-fandom matching. I don't think the selections are as freeform as the vidder self-effacingly claims -- I found it to be a pretty cohesive study of characters who are crazy, disturbed, or otherwise troubling.
other reviews: BSGvidder(s):
sdwolfpup title: Fix You music: Coldplay
focus: ensemble
availability: download (divx avi),
imeem summary: They just want to help.
comments: The vid that prefigures the WGA strike! Seriously, though, its brilliance haunts me, day and night. I hear this was a test case for living-room vs. con approaches -- apparently the VVC audience had very different reactions depending on whether they were familiar with the show. I taught a section around it once, and we discussed how our varied interpretive competencies affect the meaning we can draw from it. The uninitiates did, in fact, seem to get the gist of the narrative, enough for us to go on to the very complex question of how this vid aligns the viewer in terms of identification, and how we might extrapolate from these alignments to the extratextual battle that frames it -- the one between fans and TPTB. In conclusion, one of the most fruitful critical projects I've ever seen executed in a vid.
vidder(s):
sockkpuppett (luminosity)
title: More Human Than Human music: ?
focus: Cylons
availability: download (divx avi, wmv),
imeem summary: -----
comments: My favorite vid about BSG's technicities. Beautiful editing, brutal energy, and a palpable attention to the materiality of Cylons (including the non-humanform models) as machines. I have also taught this vid in classes.
vidder(s):
flummery title: Jerusalem music: Anouk
focus: Laura, Kara, Sharon
availability: download (divx avi, etc.),
imeem summary: ---- (VVC05)
comments: A female-driven epic swept along by a thrillingly perfect song choice. It's everything these women are: uncompromising, tragic, violent, complex, and full of grace. I don't think I have the technical vocabulary to explain why it's so gorgeous -- but believe me, it is. The structure is flawless: the characters are clearly delineated in sections, but always interconnected.
vidder(s):
tallulah71 title: Sunday Bloody Sunday music: U2
focus: ensemble
availability: download (avi)
summary: A general BSG vid showcasing the similarities between humans and cylons.
comments: Yeah, I also went, "really? isn't that a bit heavy-handed?" but it turns out to be everything one could possibly want from a vid to this song. It manages to be simultaneously a biting political commentary and a heart-wrenching emotional juggernaut. And there are these beautiful sequences of parallel clips in it about humans and cylons, in hate and in love. (And iamsab said, "it had really good 'people pointing guns at each other while trembling.' not just Lee. he's usually the trembler.") It gives me chills, man, every time.
vidder(s):
keewick title: Signal to Noise music: Peter Gabriel
focus: ensemble
availability: download (avi)
summary: "All the while the world is turning to noise/Oh the more that it's surrounding us/The more that it destroys/Turn up the signal/Wipe out the noise"
comments: I think I skipped this the first time through because it's listed as a Lee vid. Wow, is it so much more than a Lee vid. It's a beautiful and thought-providing ensemble piece that draws out the parallels and imbrications between technology and theology in BSG -- a theme that makes me fail with glee. Screens and computers, serpents and haptics, humans and cylons.
vidder(s):
super_kc title: Meant Well: The Occupation music: "Hide and Seek" by Imogen Heap
focus: ensemble
availability: download, imeem, youtube, zshare
summary: The story of the occupation of New Caprica and the people left on the ground.
comments: A visually stunning and quietly disturbing portrait of the occupation. The ending sequence with Hera just gutted me.
vidder(s):
dualbunny title: God Is A DJ music: Pink
focus: Starbuck
availability: download (divx avi, wmv)
summary: Kara says get your ass on the dance floor!
comments: I'd be hard pressed not to say this is the greatest Starbuck character study ever made. It's her destiny before she had a "destiny": just dancing to the beat of the divine (Pink is, actually, God, right?). The work with movement in this vid is incredible, and it's exuberant and in-your-face and profound all at once. [see also: the sequel,
Cuz I Can ]
vidder(s):
gwyn_r title: There music: Grey Eye Glances
focus: Laura Roslin
availability: download (divx avi), password provided; hopefully coming soon to her imeem
summary: How do you sustain hope in others in the face of unimaginable loss, when you're in danger of losing hope yourself?
comments: I kinda hate the song choice, personally, but there are many other things to love about this vid. It tells the story of a spiritual journey -- a very emotional, human one, rather than a remote theology as it's sometimes rendered. A notable Laura character study.
vidder(s):
beccatoria title: Jesus Walks music: Kanye West
focus: Laura Roslin
availability: download (wmv)
summary: Laura Roslin's not allowed to rap about Jesus.
comments: This probably remains my personal and subjective favorite BSG vid of all time. Laura, in all her power, conviction, desperation, and contradictions. The tension between the song and the source is generative of such richness. (Watch with the BtVS Gunn vid to "Jesus Walks" for maximum cognitive dissonance.) [see also:
Jesus Walks , a Gunn (BtVS) character study by
mimisere ]
vidder(s):
beccatoria title: Hummingbird Song music: Tom McRae
focus: Kendra, Cain, Gina
availability: download (wmv)
summary: "It is such a quiet thing, to fall. But far more terrible is to admit it." (Quote: Kreia SW EU)
comments: I can only speak subjectively about this vid, which juxtaposes some of Razor's most brutal scenes and themes with a sort of sad lullaby; YMMV. I found it so achingly... romantic. it's the music, but also my personal ability to see all Razor's horrific violence as the fruits of profound and tragic love between women. includes some of my favorite Cain/Gina sequences so far in a vid -- they just gutted me. and the Kendra POVishness is great, totally chilling (and with Kendra and Gina, glee!). It feels dreamlike, with all the fades to black. so gorgeous! it's hard to explain how the material meshed with the song, to me -- it was like hallucinating? sort of hushed or hazy, not tempering the impact of the violence, which is laid out very potently, but making it seem far far away, a memory.
vidder(s):
kiki_miserychic title: Ain't No Reason music: Brett Dennen
focus: Kendra, Cain, Gina, Kara
availability: download (wmv/divx), stage6
summary: A character and relationship study of the women of Battlestar Galactica: Razor.
comments: A gently both beautiful and political meditation on Razor, which does a great job of evocatively incorporating its larger context of war and heartbreak. Hints of Cain/Kendra and Cain/Gina.
vidder(s):
drgnfille title: I Already Met You music: Superfine
focus: Cylons (humor, het)
availability: download (wmv)
summary: It's about the various versions of the cylon agents and their wacky escapades with the humans who love (and hate) them.
comments: "I already met you / you're like my last girlfriend / and the girlfriend I had before her" - A delightfully snarky romp through the myriad relationships between humans and cylons. In addition to the hilarity, it offers a clever commentary on the mindfrak of living with/as many copies.
vidder(s):
martoufmarty title: Sex, Violence, and Cylons music: Violent Pornography by System of a Down
focus: ensemble (humor, het)
availability: download (mpg), imeem
summary: Warning: Video contains coarse language, violence, and sexual content throughout. Parental absence is suggested. Contains scenes from the mini-series all the way until episode 2x19.
comments: Partly amusing, partly DISTURBING! It might be perverse to classify this vid as humor. An acid trip through BSG's more adult themes, via much excellent use of short clips. I especially love the self-reflexive touch